Responding to Rob's Art

Okay, for so I couldn't login, and created my post as a comment on Robs (which is technically what it is), but now I can, so I will create a post!

I like "B" as well, but I agree that losing the background and reflection might give us more of an idea of how we can convert it to be used for more purposes. Also, what it looks like with/without the word church or the tagline. I still like "C" though. I lke the font better, and I still fear the drop of water is too literal; I find the waves a little more visually appealing (and pretty:) But I do like B. I am not as big of a fan of the others, and out of "E" still the one with the sideways drop is most appealing, but maybe because it looks less like a drop? And I don't love the font in E. :/ I am not feeling "A" as a timeless design. So overall, my contribution is pretty similar to the feedback provided by the other designers. Great job Rob, these are really great. Are you pleased with them? I am sorry that I have not gotten the chance to create any more, but I think Rob has done some great work!